Mastering Online Review Management for Your Business

In today’s digital landscape, your online reputation is often the first thing a potential customer sees before they even set foot in your shop or visit your website. For Australian small businesses, managing online reviews isn't just about damage control; it is a powerful form of social proof that can significantly impact your local SEO and overall sales.

Why Review Management Matters

Think of online reviews as the modern-day word-of-mouth. A high rating on Google or ProductReview.com.au tells prospective clients that you are reliable and trustworthy. Conversely, ignored reviews—even positive ones—can make a business look indifferent. By actively managing your reviews, you take control of your brand narrative and show your community that you value their feedback.

---

Prerequisites: What You’ll Need

Before you dive in, ensure you have the following ready:

• Access to your Google Business Profile: Ensure you are an owner or manager of your listing.
• Login details for secondary sites: This includes Facebook, Yelp, or industry-specific sites like TripAdvisor or Houzz.
• Your ABN (Australian Business Number): Sometimes required for verifying your business identity on certain platforms.
• A professional headshot or company logo: To ensure your profiles look complete and credible.

---

Step 1: Audit Your Current Online Presence

Start by searching for your business name on Google. Look beyond the first page. You need to identify every platform where customers are talking about you.

Step 2: Claim Your Listings

If you haven't already, "claim" your business on Google, Facebook, and Bing Places. This usually involves a verification process where the platform may send a code via post to your Australian business address or via a phone call.

Step 3: Set Up Review Notifications

You can’t respond quickly if you don’t know a review has been posted. Go into the settings of your Google Business Profile and Facebook Page and toggle on email or push notifications for new reviews.

Step 4: Create a Response Template Library

While you should never copy-paste the exact same response to every customer, having a framework helps. Create three templates:

• The Positive Response: Thank them, mention a specific detail they liked, and invite them back.
• The Neutral Response: Thank them for the feedback and ask how you could improve to reach five stars next time.
• The Negative Response: Stay calm, apologise for the experience, and offer to take the conversation offline.

Step 5: Respond to Positive Reviews Within 24-48 Hours

When someone leaves a five-star review, they are doing you a massive favour. Acknowledge it! Use their name and mention the specific service or product they bought.

Step 6: Address Negative Reviews Professionally

Negative reviews happen to the best businesses. The key is your reaction.

• Don't get defensive: Even if the customer is wrong, remember that you are writing for the future customers reading the response.
• Apologise sincerely: "We're sorry to hear your experience didn't meet our usual high standards."
• Move it offline: Provide a phone number or email address (e.g., "Please contact us at info@yourbusiness.com.au so we can make this right.").

Step 7: Flag Fraudulent or Spam Reviews

If you receive a review that is clearly fake (e.g., from someone who was never a customer or contains offensive language), use the 'Report' or 'Flag' tool.

Step 8: Build a System to Ask for Reviews

Don't leave your reputation to chance. Happy customers often forget to leave reviews, while unhappy ones rarely do. Create a process to ask for feedback:

• After a sale: Send a follow-up email with a direct link to your Google review page.
• In-store: Use a QR code on your counter or business cards.
• SMS: If you use SMS marketing, send a brief text 24 hours after service delivery.

Step 9: Use Reviews in Your Marketing

Once you have great reviews, flaunt them! Take a screenshot of a glowing testimonial and share it on your Instagram or Facebook page. This reinforces your credibility to your followers.

Step 10: Monitor and Adjust

Set aside 15 minutes every Friday to review your sentiment trends. Are people complaining about the wait times? Is one specific staff member getting all the praise? Use this data to improve your actual business operations.

---

Pro Tips for Success

• Include Keywords: When responding to reviews, naturally include your service and location. E.g., "We are so glad we could help with your plumbing emergency in Brisbane."
• Don't Incentivise: Under Australian Consumer Law (overseen by the ACCC), it is illegal to offer gifts, discounts, or money in exchange for reviews. This is considered misleading conduct.
• Be Human: Avoid sounding like a corporate robot. Use a friendly, local tone that reflects your brand personality.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Ignoring the 'Silent' Reviews: Don't just respond to 1-star and 5-star reviews. Those 3-star reviews often contain the most helpful constructive criticism.
• Buying Reviews: Never buy fake reviews. Google’s algorithms are incredibly sophisticated and will likely penalise your ranking or suspend your listing entirely.
• Getting into an Argument: Never engage in a back-and-forth shouting match online. It makes the business look unprofessional, regardless of who is right.

---

Troubleshooting Common Issues

---

Next Steps

Managing your reputation is an ongoing process. Now that you have a system for responding, why not automate the request process?

If you find managing multiple platforms overwhelming or need help removing unfair content, the team at Local Marketing Group can help. We specialise in reputation management for Brisbane businesses.